Be leery of “pigeon-holing” your approach too soon. You need time to figure out which way(s) works best for your family. There is no right or wrong way to homeschool. If you can imagine it, you can try it!
Here are some of the popular methods:
Possible Disadvantages: May be expensive. May lead to burn-out if you try to follow the box curriculum exactly. Because they are modeled after traditional classroom teaching methods, textbook programs may not meet the needs of all learning styles. A child is often not in the same “grade level” in all subjects and box curriculum doesn’t take that into consideration. If you have taken a child out of school because it wasn’t working for that child, then recreating school-at-home may not be a good option.
Possible Advantages: The advantage of this style is that families know exactly what to teach and when to teach it. That can be a comfort when you are just starting out.
Possible Disadvantages: Some topics may be challenging to find or create curriculum for.
Possible Advantages: Packaged unit studies are available on many popular topics and it is often easy to piece together unit studies yourself. Perhaps the biggest advantage of this homeschooling method is that it recognizes the fact that people learn best when they are interested in the topic.
Possible Disadvantages: Most Montessori materials are for younger children so it may be challenging to find what is available for high school students.
Possible Advantages: It may be easier to fit into a natural flow of life than some other homeschooling methods.
Possible Disadvantages: Possibly more effort needed by the parent to gather resources.
Possible Advantages: Easily tailored to each child’s needs and easy to switch paths as needed.
Possible Disadvantages: There may be perceived gaps in the education. You may be juggling many balls at once as interests are added and changed.
Possible Advantages: The cost of learning in this way is completely flexible. You can spend a lot on classes and materials or very little. There is buy-in from the children since they are instrumental in creating the path.
Possible Disadvantages: Some people do not consider this “homeschooling.” Some states do not legally recognize these programs. These schools may have strict guidelines you need to adhere to, including regular teacher meetings. This may feel stifling compared to not having someone to answer to.
Possible Advantages: Some provide transcripts. A family may feel they are on the right track with their child’s education if they know someone is “approving” it. Some offer extracurricular activities and classes.
Possible Disadvantages: Similar to “School-at-home” this inflexible complete package may not fit the needs of a single child. It is not uncommon to hear that a child “burns out” on this sort of program. Parent may feel disconnected from their child’s education.
Possible Advantages: Parents do not need to be as involved in this learning, which could be beneficial in some “busy parent” households. Children work independently. Correcting, grading of work and record keeping is automatically done. Some programs have regular virtual meetings with teachers.
There are many other options for homeschool: Classical, Charlotte Mason, Whole-Hearted Learning, Religious-based programs, Waldorf, Self-Learning/Independent Study, etc. A variety of homeschool articles and blogs are online and can help you learn more about all these homeschooling methods.